Image of a couple looking out at a sunset discussing financial planning.

Common Mistakes Married Couples Make When Buying Life Insurance

Think of life insurance as the financial safety net your family would need if the unthinkable happened

Buying life insurance is one of the most important financial decisions married couples make. It’s not just about checking a box, it’s about safeguarding your family’s future. Yet, many couples unintentionally stumble into pitfalls that leave their loved ones vulnerable. Let’s explore some of the most common mistakes and, more importantly, how to sidestep them.

If you’re searching for advice about life insurance for married couples, this guide will help you make informed decisions, protect your loved ones, and avoid the traps many fall into.

Coverage Mistakes

Underestimating Coverage Needs

Think of life insurance as the financial safety net your family would need if the unthinkable happened. A lot of couples fall into the trap of relying on a basic employer plan, often offering coverage equal to 1–2 times their annual salary. It seems like enough until you do the math.

Experts suggest aiming for 20–30 times your annual income. Why? Because life doesn’t get cheaper when you’re gone. For instance, if you earn $50,000 a year, a $1–1.5 million policy ensures your family won’t struggle to keep up with bills, education costs, or mortgage payments.

Imagine a young family where one spouse passes away unexpectedly. Without enough coverage, the surviving partner may face a mountain of expenses, from daycare to paying off the mortgage. Proper coverage keeps their future secure.

Relying Solely on Employer Coverage

Your workplace policy might feel like a warm safety blanket, but here’s the catch: it doesn’t follow you if you switch jobs. Plus, it often falls short on coverage. An individual policy, one you control, provides long-term peace of mind.

Policy Selection Errors

Choosing the Wrong Policy Type

Picking between term and permanent insurance is more than a budget decision; it’s about matching your policy to your life’s timeline. Imagine you’re parents of young kids. A 10-year term policy might feel sufficient today, but what happens when it lapses before your children are adults? A longer-term or permanent policy may better suit your needs.

Focusing Only on Premium Costs

Yes, budget matters. But here’s the thing: the cheapest policy isn’t always the best. A bargain-bin insurer might struggle, or even fail, to pay claims when your family needs them most. Research the company’s financial strength and reputation before signing on the dotted line. A policy from a reputable company costs a bit more upfront but ensures reliability when it matters most.

Timing Mistakes

Waiting Too Long to Buy Coverage

Life insurance costs increase with age. The younger (and healthier) you are, the less you’ll pay. Lock in a policy now, even if it’s not ideal. You can always adjust coverage later. What you can’t do is turn back time.

Consider this: a couple in their 20s pays significantly less in monthly premiums than the same couple in their 40s. Plus, younger buyers often qualify for better rates due to fewer health risks. Waiting might save short-term dollars but can cost thousands over the life of the policy.

Beneficiary Designation Errors

Designating beneficiaries may sound straightforward, but it’s one of the most common areas where couples make costly mistakes. Here are the key issues, with examples and how to avoid them:

  1. Not Being Specific Enough
    Vague beneficiary designations can lead to disputes or delays in accessing funds. For example, if you simply name “my spouse” as a beneficiary without specifying their legal name, complications may arise if you later divorce and remarry. Always provide full legal names and confirm that they match other important documents.
  2. Naming Minors as Primary Beneficiaries
    Children under 18 cannot legally receive life insurance payouts directly. If you name a minor as your beneficiary, the funds will typically be placed into a court-appointed trust until the child comes of age. This process can delay access to the funds when they’re needed most.
    How to Avoid This:

    • Set up a trust to manage the payout on behalf of your children.
    • Name the trust as the policy beneficiary and appoint a trusted guardian to oversee the funds.
  3. Failing to Specify Contingent Beneficiaries
    Life happens, and sometimes your primary beneficiary cannot receive the payout. For instance, if you and your spouse are in a fatal accident, and you haven’t named a contingent beneficiary, the proceeds may go through probate. This can delay distribution and create legal complications.
    Solution: Always name a secondary (contingent) beneficiary, someone you trust to receive the benefits if the primary is unable to do so. Common choices include siblings, parents, or adult children.
  4. Not Keeping Beneficiary Information Updated
    Over time, families grow and change. Outdated beneficiary designations might exclude newer family members or include individuals you no longer wish to benefit, like a former spouse.
    Example: A couple who divorced forgot to update their policies, and when one partner passed, the life insurance payout went to the ex-spouse rather than the children.
    Solution: Make it a habit to review and update beneficiaries every few years or after major life events, like marriage, divorce, or the birth of a child.

Joint Policy Considerations

Relationship Status Complications

Joint policies can be a good option for married couples, but they come with potential risks. Divorce, for example, complicates joint policy management. You may face administrative headaches or even need new health underwriting to replace the policy.

If you’re considering a joint policy, ask yourself: “What happens if we separate?” Evaluating the pros and cons with a financial advisor can save you trouble down the line.

Health Impact on Premiums

If one spouse has significant health issues, a joint policy might cost more than separate individual policies. Comparing both options ensures you’re not overpaying for coverage unnecessarily.

Regular Review Failures

Neglecting to Update Policies

Life evolves. Your insurance should too. Major milestones, like having kids, buying a house, or career changes, are signals to review your coverage. Experts suggest revisiting your policy every three years to ensure it still fits your needs.

Example:
A young couple purchased a term policy when they were renting a small apartment. Years later, with a bigger home, two kids, and a higher income, their initial coverage no longer matched their financial needs. Regular reviews prevent gaps like this.

Final Thoughts

Buying life insurance isn’t just a financial decision; it’s a love letter to your family’s future. Avoiding these common mistakes ensures your policy will do what it’s supposed to, protect your loved ones when they need it most. Whether you’re exploring life insurance for married couples or updating an existing policy, taking a thoughtful, proactive approach is key.

The best policy is the one that grows with your family and meets their needs, now and in the future. Take your time, ask questions, and revisit your coverage regularly. After all, your family deserves nothing less.